top of page

What if I don’t fit in? A guide for men who fear joining new groups

Nov 2
10 min read

You don’t need to be the same as everyone else. You need enough common ground to feel comfortable being yourself.

There's a photograph on Facebook.

Twenty men standing together after a walk.

Everyone looks as though they're having a good time.

And your first thought isn't:

“That looks good.”

It's:

“I wouldn't fit in with them.”

Interesting.

Because you haven't met any of them.

You don't know what they do.

Where they're from.

Whether they're married.

Divorced.

Retired.

Working.

Struggling.

Confident.

Quiet.

Complete idiots.

You have almost no information.

Yet somehow your brain has already conducted the interviews and rejected your application.

That's what fear of not fitting in can do.

It fills gaps in information with assumptions.

Usually ones that keep you exactly where you are.


a man standing on the outer edge of a group of friends

What does “fitting in” actually mean?

We use the phrase without thinking much about it.

“They're not really my sort of people.”

Who are your sort of people?

Same age?

Job?

Income?

Politics?

Football team?

Music?

Personality?

Background?

Most friendship groups are far more mixed than they first appear.

People don't necessarily become friends because they're identical.

They need enough common ground for a relationship to begin.

Sometimes that common ground is remarkably small.

You both enjoy walking.

You're both dads.

You both moved to Plymouth.

You both support Argyle.

You both think getting up at 6am for a freezing sea swim sounds completely ridiculous.

That's enough to start a conversation.

You can discover the rest later.


What's actually going on?

Human beings pay close attention to belonging.

We notice:

Am I welcome here?

Do people like me?

Am I behaving correctly?

Am I different from everyone else?


That's useful social information.

But when we're uncertain, we can become biased towards detecting possible rejection.

We look around and compare ourselves.

He's younger.

He's fitter.

Those two already know each other.

They seem more confident.

Everyone else looks relaxed.

Therefore:

“I'm the one who doesn't belong.”

Except there's something you've forgotten.

You're comparing how they look externally with how you feel internally.

The bloke who looks completely comfortable might have sat in his car for ten minutes before coming in.

You wouldn't know.


The MoMENtum insight: The Belonging Trap™

I think there's a simple trap here:

I need to feel that I belong

↓

before I'll participate

↓

but belonging develops through participation

↓

so I never stay long enough to develop it


That's The Belonging Trap™.

We expect the feeling to come first.

Often the behaviour has to come first.

You turn up.

Then return.

People become familiar.

Someone remembers your name.

You know where everyone meets.

You start recognising the regulars.

Then one day you realise something has changed.

You're not wondering whether you belong anymore.

You're just there.


Belonging isn't instant chemistry

This is where expectations can cause problems.

We expect new friendships to somehow feel immediately natural.

Perhaps because we forget how old friendships actually developed.

Your oldest mate may now feel completely effortless.

But you've known him for twenty-five years.

You have thousands of shared experiences.

Private jokes.

Arguments.

Holidays.

Bad decisions.

Good decisions.

Possibly several decisions neither of you should ever mention again.

You cannot reproduce twenty-five years of familiarity in a 90-minute walk.

New relationships initially feel newer.

That's not a defect.

It's maths.

a note book with a reminder that you dont need to fir in

Alan's perspective

I think men are sometimes far too quick to decide:

“They're not my type.”

after spending about eleven minutes with somebody.

I've done it.

We all make snap judgements.

Then you actually talk to the person.

And discover the bloke you assumed you had nothing in common with is funny as hell.

Or has been through something similar to you.

Or knows exactly what you're talking about.

That's one of the things I like about MoMENtum.

We're not trying to create a group of identical men.

That would be awful.

Imagine thirty versions of me in one room.

I'd leave.

Different ages.

Different jobs.

Different backgrounds.

Different personalities.

That's fine.

What matters is whether people can treat each other decently and enjoy being around each other.

You don't need to agree about everything to share a coffee.


The fear of being judged

This is often sitting underneath:

“I won't fit in.”

What if they think I'm boring?

What if I'm awkward?

What if they ask why I've come?

What if they can tell I haven't got many friends?

Here's the disappointing truth.

Most people are thinking considerably more about themselves than they are about you.

They're wondering:

“Do I look alright?”

“Should I say something?”

“Does everyone else know each other?”

“Where are we supposed to meet?”

You may imagine a room full of men assessing you.

In reality, you may have walked into a room containing six men each wondering whether everyone is assessing them.


🔎 What I see at MoMENtum

The men who worry about fitting in are often exactly the men who assume everybody else arrived confident.

They didn't.

Some came alone.

Some were nervous.

Some didn't know anybody.

Some nearly didn't come.

That's worth remembering.

Established members aren't a separate species called:

People Who Naturally Join Groups.

At some point, every regular attended for the first time.

The only difference is that they came back.


You don't have to be outgoing

There's another assumption:

“Groups are for sociable people.”

Not necessarily.

Groups contain:

the bloke who talks to everybody;

the bloke who talks to two people;

the bloke who listens more than he talks;

the bloke who takes twenty minutes to warm up;

and usually somebody who could apparently start a conversation with a parking meter.

All legitimate.

You don't have to compete with the loudest person in the room.

Belonging doesn't mean becoming like them.

It means having enough room to remain like you.


What psychological safety actually means

“Psychological safety” can sound like corporate training language.

In a social group, I'd make it much simpler.

You need to know:

I can turn up without being made to look stupid.

I don't have to disclose personal information.

I can speak without being attacked.

I can be quiet without being interrogated.

I can disagree respectfully.

I can leave if this isn't for me.

That's enough.

A social group should have standards.

Being welcoming doesn't mean accepting every kind of behaviour.

If someone is aggressive, discriminatory or consistently makes other members uncomfortable, the group's responsibility to create a decent environment matters more than one person's right to behave however they like.

Belonging requires boundaries too.

three men stood chatting

You don't need everyone's approval

This is liberating once you realise it.

Suppose twenty men attend an event.

You probably aren't going to become friends with all twenty.

Why would you?

You don't like everyone you work with.

You don't like every neighbour.

You probably don't even like every member of your extended family.

The goal isn't:

“Every man here must like me.”

It's:

“Is there anyone here I get on with?”

One or two good conversations can be enough.


The Three-Person Test™

Instead of assessing an entire group, try this.

Find three people.

Person one

Someone easy to say hello to.


Person two

Someone you have something in common with.


Person three

Someone you'd happily speak to again.

They may be the same person.

That's fine.

This is The Three-Person Test™.

You're reducing:

“Do I fit into this entire social group?”

to:

“Can I find one or two people here I quite like?”

Much easier.


What if everyone seems different from me?

Different isn't automatically bad.

Age differences can be useful.

Different careers give you something to talk about.

Different life experiences make conversations interesting.

Friendship doesn't require demographic cloning.

There may be things that matter more:

Humour.

Kindness.

Reliability.

Curiosity.

Not taking yourself too seriously.

Being able to listen.

Turning up.

Those qualities cross age, class and profession surprisingly well.

But sometimes you genuinely won't fit in

Let's not pretend otherwise.

You might try a group and dislike it.

Perhaps the atmosphere isn't right.

Perhaps the activity isn't for you.

Perhaps the people genuinely aren't people you want to spend time with.

Fine.

Leaving one group isn't social failure.

It means you tested something and got an answer.

The mistake is turning:

“I didn't like that group”

into:

“Groups aren't for me.”

That's like having one terrible curry and deciding food isn't your thing.

Try somewhere else.


The bit nobody tells you: you may have to tolerate being ordinary

This one is interesting.

In established parts of life, you have an identity.

At work, perhaps you're the boss.

At home, Dad.

Among old friends, everybody knows your history.

Then you enter a new group.

Nobody knows any of that.

You're simply:

Alan, the new bloke.

That can feel strangely uncomfortable.

You don't have status yet.

Nobody knows what you're good at.

Nobody knows your stories.

You are temporarily ordinary.

That's actually quite healthy.

Let people discover you slowly.

You don't need to prove your value before you're allowed to belong.


Don't audition

This follows directly from that.

You don't need to become:

funnier;

more confident;

more successful;

more interesting;

more knowledgeable.

People can normally tell when somebody is trying very hard to impress them.

Relax.

Ask questions.

Listen.

Say something when you've got something to say.

You aren't applying for membership of the SAS.

It's coffee.


What if I've been rejected before?

This can make joining particularly difficult.

Perhaps you were bullied.

Excluded.

Lost friendships badly.

Went through a difficult divorce.

Experienced rejection.

Those experiences can teach you to protect yourself.

Then a new social situation isn't entirely new.

Your brain brings old evidence with it.

“Last time I trusted people, this happened.”

That's understandable.

But old experiences don't perfectly predict new people.

You don't have to trust everyone immediately.

You can test gradually.

Turn up.

Observe.

Talk.

Return.

Let people demonstrate who they are.

Trust doesn't need to be blind.


Why regular groups help

Regularity gives you multiple opportunities to update your first impression.

Perhaps the first time you speak to nobody much.

Second time, better.

Third time, you meet somebody new.

Fourth time, you discover one of the blokes lives around the corner.

That's how social networks grow.

Slowly.

This is also why I don't think success should be judged solely by:

“Did I make a friend tonight?”

A better question is:

“Am I becoming more familiar here?”

Familiarity is progress.


If you're new to Plymouth

This deserves mentioning because moving somewhere new as an adult can be difficult.

You haven't got:

school friends;

old workmates;

family history;

the bloke you've known since 1997.

Everyone else appears established.

So you need somewhere that creates repeated contact deliberately.

That's one of the roles local groups can play.

You don't need to wait five years before Plymouth starts feeling like home.

But you probably do need to put yourself somewhere beyond your house and workplace.


If you've separated or divorced

You may be rebuilding more than a relationship.

Your whole social structure may have changed.

Weekends.

Friends.

Routines.

Invitations.

Perhaps you've lost contact with people you knew mainly as couples.

Walking into something new while you're already feeling unsettled can be difficult.

Don't set yourself the additional requirement of:

“I must immediately rebuild my social circle.”

Just create somewhere to go.

That's enough initially.


If you're a dad whose life has become work and family

You don't need to feel guilty for wanting something outside those roles.

Being a good partner or dad doesn't require having no independent social life.

A couple of hours with other men doesn't mean you're rejecting your family.

It means you remain a person as well as a role.

That's healthy.


🌱 One small step this week

If you're thinking about joining something, don't ask:

“Will I fit in?”

You don't have enough information.

Replace it with:

“What would I need to know before I'd be willing to try it once?”

Maybe you need:

the location;

time;

number of people;

what happens;

whether you can come alone;

whether you need to book;

how long it lasts.

Find those answers.

Then make the decision using information instead of imagination.


Frequently asked questions

Why am I scared I won't fit into a group?

New social situations involve uncertainty about acceptance, behaviour and belonging. Previous experiences of rejection or simply being unfamiliar with groups can increase that discomfort.


Does feeling uncomfortable mean the group is wrong for me?

Not necessarily. Newness itself can feel uncomfortable. Give yourself enough experience to distinguish ordinary first-time nerves from genuine incompatibility.


What if I'm much younger or older than everyone else?

Age can affect whether a group suits you, but it doesn't automatically prevent connection. Shared interests, humour, values and life experiences can matter more.


What if I'm quiet?

You don't have to be highly talkative to participate. Good groups should allow different personalities rather than rewarding only the loudest members.


How do I know whether a group is welcoming?

Look at how newcomers are treated. Are you acknowledged? Introduced? Given information? Included without being pressured? Those behaviours tell you more than a claim that “everyone is friendly”.


What if nobody likes me?

You don't need everybody to like you. Look for one or two people you enjoy talking to rather than seeking approval from an entire group.


How many times should I try a group?

There's no fixed rule. If nothing feels seriously wrong, two or three visits can give a more reliable impression than one because some initial discomfort will have reduced.


What if I don't like anyone there?

Try another activity or group. One poor fit doesn't tell you whether other groups will suit you.


Is MoMENtum only for lonely men?

No. Men attend for different reasons: friendship, activity, meeting people, getting out more, being new to Plymouth or simply wanting a wider social circle.


Do I have to explain why I've joined?

No. “Thought I'd come along” is a perfectly adequate explanation.


Will I have to talk about mental health?

No. MoMENtum isn't group therapy. You're free to talk about your life, but personal disclosure isn't required.


Can I come on my own?

Yes. You do not need to already know somebody in order to attend a group designed to help men meet people.


The MoMENtum question

Here's the question:

“Who exactly have you decided won't accept you — without actually meeting them?”

It's worth thinking about.

Because sometimes rejection happens.

That's life.

But sometimes we reject ourselves on everybody else's behalf.

We decide:

they're younger;

they're different;

they're more confident;

they've already got friends;

therefore:

“I don't belong.”

Maybe.

But perhaps the bloke you're looking at is thinking exactly the same thing.

Belonging isn't something a group can promise you before you've met anyone.

And friendship can't be guaranteed.

What we can do is create the conditions.

A decent welcome.

Something to do.

No pressure to perform.

No compulsory emotional disclosure.

Regular opportunities to return.

Then you get to decide.

Not from a photograph.

Not from the car.

Not from whatever your brain predicted the night before.

From actual experience.

You may discover MoMENtum isn't for you.

That's perfectly acceptable.

But you may also discover that the men you assumed wouldn't be your sort of people are actually just blokes trying to get out, meet people and have a decent couple of hours.

Rather like you.

You don't need to know that you'll fit in before you arrive. You need somewhere safe enough to find out.

Comments


Momentum logo

Building stronger connections, one event, one conversation and one friendship at a time.

Don't worry! We won't spam you!

  • Facebook
  • Instagram

Copyright © 2025 by Momentum | All Rights Reserved.

bottom of page