top of page

How men can build connection without “opening up” or oversharing

Oct 26
9 min read

You don’t have to tell strangers your life story to feel less isolated

There is a particular sentence that makes a lot of men switch off immediately:

“You just need to open up more.”

Maybe.

But to whom?

About what?

How much?

And why does every conversation about male loneliness seem to end with somebody trying to get men to discuss their deepest emotions with a stranger?

I think we’ve made this harder than it needs to be.

Connection doesn’t have to begin with disclosure.

Sometimes it begins with:

“Fancy a coffee?”

Or:

“You coming on the walk Sunday?”

Or:

“Did you see the match?”

That counts.

You don’t have to stand in a circle and announce your childhood wounds before you’re allowed to feel connected to other people.

Sometimes trust comes first.

The talking comes later.

And sometimes the friendship is valuable even if the talking never becomes particularly deep.


a group of men out on a walk

Connection is bigger than emotional disclosure

There’s an idea floating around that the only “real” friendship is one where everybody talks openly about feelings.

I don’t think that’s true.

Research does show that intimacy can be strengthened through vulnerable disclosure and responsiveness, and some men disclose distress less readily than women or than they do with female partners.

That matters.

But it isn’t the whole story.

A 2026 ethnographic study of male railway volunteers in Northern England found meaningful friendships could develop around shared activity even where overt emotional disclosure was deliberately limited. The point was not that disclosure is useless, but that emotional reticence does not automatically mean there is no intimacy or support.


That fits something I’ve believed for a while:

Men don’t all need to communicate in the same way before their relationships count.

Some friendships are built through conversation.

Some through doing.

Most contain a bit of both.


What’s actually going on?

For some men, activity makes social contact easier because it removes the pressure to perform socially.

Think about the difference between these two situations.


Situation A

Six men sitting in a circle.

Nothing to do except talk.

Everyone facing each other.

Silence feels obvious.


Situation B

Six men walking.

You’re side by side.

There’s something happening around you.

Silence is normal.

Conversation starts and stops.

You can talk to one person rather than the entire group.

For many men, the second setting simply feels easier.

Recent research on Men’s Sheds describes this kind of activity-based, side-by-side socialisation as one mechanism that can make connection more accessible to men, while shared activity provides routine and creates conditions in which relationships can develop.

That doesn’t mean men are biologically incapable of face-to-face conversation.

It means environment matters.

If you want people to connect, make connection easier.


The MoMENtum insight: Connection Before Disclosure™

I think we often have the order backwards.

We expect:

Disclosure

↓

Trust

↓

Connection

But for plenty of men, it works more like:

Shared activity

↓

Familiarity

↓

Trust

↓

Connection

↓

Maybe disclosure

That is Connection Before Disclosure™.

The key word is maybe.


three man having a coffee together

There is no rule saying every friendship must eventually become deeply confessional.

But once trust exists, harder conversations become more possible.

You’re no longer telling “a man from the group”.

You’re telling Dave.

That’s different.


Why “open up” can feel like pressure rather than support

Imagine somebody joins a men’s group because he’s recently separated.

He doesn’t know anyone.

He’s already slightly uncomfortable about attending.

Then within ten minutes someone asks:

“So what’s going on for you emotionally?”

Congratulations.

He may never come back.

Not because he’s incapable of emotional honesty.

Because nobody has earned that conversation yet.

We wouldn’t normally expect personal disclosure from strangers in other areas of life.

Trust takes time.

Why should men’s wellbeing spaces be different?

You can create an environment where honesty is welcome without making honesty compulsory.

That distinction matters enormously.


Alan’s perspective

This is one of the strongest views I have about MoMENtum.

I don’t want to trick men into therapy.

If somebody needs therapy, there are proper therapeutic services.

MoMENtum is social.

That means you’re allowed to simply enjoy being there.

You can come on a walk and talk about football for an hour.

You can sit over breakfast and take the piss out of someone.

You can talk about work.

Your kids.

Cars.

Your divorce.

Your prostate.

The price of everything.

Whatever comes up.

I’m not standing nearby with a clipboard thinking:

“He still hasn’t disclosed an emotion.”

That would completely miss the point.

Sometimes the fact a man has got out of the house, spent two hours around other people and laughed is enough for that day.

And once he’s been coming for a while, maybe something more serious comes up.

If it does, there are people around him he already knows.

That’s where the group has done something valuable without ever pretending to be therapy.


Humour is connection too

I think we underestimate this.

Men often use humour to connect.

Sometimes to avoid.

Yes.

But not every joke is a defence mechanism requiring professional intervention.

Shared humour creates:

  • familiarity;

  • shared language;

  • memories;

  • belonging.

Someone remembering the ridiculous thing that happened on the last walk is part of relationship-building.

Being able to laugh with people is not a lesser form of connection than talking seriously with them.

Healthy friendships can contain both.


three men laughing together

🔎 What I see at MoMENtum

The deeper conversations usually don’t happen because we scheduled them.

They happen while something else is going on.

On a walk.

Over coffee.

Sitting beside somebody.

Someone mentions work is a nightmare.

Another says:

“Yeah, mine’s been like that.”

Then maybe it goes somewhere.

Or maybe it doesn’t.

That low-pressure quality matters.

Nobody feels they’ve failed the group because they weren’t vulnerable enough.

And nobody feels they’ve broken the rules because they did say something personal.

There’s space for both.


Why side-by-side connection can work

Shared activity gives friendship several things automatically.


A reason to be there

You’re walking, eating, fixing something or attending an event.


Something to discuss

You don’t need to invent conversation from nothing.


Less intense eye contact

Useful when people don’t know each other well.


Natural silence

Nobody needs to fill every second.


Repetition

You can come back and see the same people again.


That last one is crucial.

Activity doesn’t magically create friendship.

It creates conditions where friendship can develop.

That is much more realistic.

But emotional disclosure does matter sometimes

I don’t want to swing too far the other way.

There is good evidence that some men conceal distress and are less likely to disclose difficult emotions or ask for help, particularly where traditional expectations of self-sufficiency and emotional restraint are strong.

That can become a problem.

If you’re struggling badly and telling everyone:

“Yeah mate, all good.”

then companionship alone may not be enough.

Sometimes you need to say:

“Actually, things aren’t great.”

But that is very different from claiming every man needs to start every relationship with vulnerability.

My view is simpler:

Connection makes honest conversation more possible.

So build some connection first.


The Trust Ladder™

Think of it like this.

1. Shared space

You’re both there.


2. Familiarity

You recognise each other.


3. Easy conversation

Ordinary things.


4. Reliability

You keep seeing each other.


5. Trust

You have some idea who this person is.


6. Personal conversation

Now you may choose to share more.


That’s The Trust Ladder™.

The problem with forced “opening up” is that it tries to jump from stage one to stage six.

Some people can do that.

Plenty don’t want to.

There’s nothing wrong with giving trust time to develop.


What if I genuinely don’t want to talk about personal things?

Then don’t.

A social group isn’t an interrogation.

You can still benefit from:

  • routine;

  • company;

  • activity;

  • humour;

  • meeting people;

  • feeling part of something.

If at some point you want to talk more deeply to someone you trust, you can.

If you never do at the group, that doesn’t invalidate your membership.

There is no vulnerability quota.


What if I’m struggling mentally?

Then we need to distinguish social support from professional support.

If you’re persistently depressed, extremely anxious, dealing with trauma, having thoughts of self-harm or suicide, or struggling to function, talk to an appropriate professional.

A good social network can help.

It cannot replace every form of treatment.

MoMENtum can give you people and connection.

It is not a mental-health service.

That boundary protects everybody.


The bit nobody tells you: friendship can be quiet

Sometimes friendship looks like:

“You alright?”

“Yeah.”

“You sure?”

“…been better.”

“Fancy a coffee?”

That may look completely inadequate to somebody observing from outside.

But the meaning is carried by the relationship.

You don’t need a forty-minute emotional analysis every time something goes wrong.

You need enough trust that the other person notices.

And enough safety that, if you do want to say more, you can.


Why oversharing can actually make connection harder

Another thing worth saying.

More disclosure isn’t automatically better disclosure.

If you reveal intensely personal material immediately, the other person may not know how to respond.

That doesn’t mean they lack empathy.

The relationship simply may not be ready for it.

Healthy disclosure tends to be reciprocal and context-sensitive.

You share something.

See how it lands.

The relationship deepens.

Then perhaps something else becomes possible.

Connection is not a competition to see who can reveal the most painful thing first.


How to build connection without forcing conversation

Try these.

Do something recurring

Walking group.

Sport.

Coffee.

Volunteer.

Hobby.

The exact activity matters less than repetition.


Speak to the same people again

Friendship needs continuity.


Ask ordinary questions

Work.

Family.

Where they're from.

What they do.

Why they joined.


Remember something

“How did that interview go?”

Tiny detail.

Huge signal.

It tells someone you listened.


Suggest something outside the group

Eventually:

“Fancy a coffee sometime?”

That's how a group contact becomes a friendship.


🌱 One small step this week

Stop setting yourself the goal:

“I need to open up more.”

Try this instead:

“I need to spend more time around people I could eventually trust.”

Those are very different goals.

Find one recurring activity.

Go.

Talk to one bloke.

Nothing profound.

Then go again.

Let familiarity do some of the work.


Frequently asked questions

Do men need to talk about their feelings to avoid loneliness?

Not necessarily in every interaction. Emotional disclosure can strengthen intimacy and help when someone is distressed, but companionship, shared activity and repeated contact are also meaningful forms of connection.


Why do men often prefer activity-based friendships?

Research suggests some male friendships are organised more strongly around shared activities and side-by-side interaction. This is a tendency, not a rule about every man.


Is not talking about feelings unhealthy?

Not automatically. Emotional reticence can exist within meaningful friendships. It becomes more concerning when someone is distressed, needs support and feels unable to disclose or seek help.


Can men have close friendships without discussing personal issues?

Yes. Recent ethnographic research in Northern England describes meaningful male friendships built through shared activity where overt personal disclosure was limited.


What does “side-by-side connection” mean?

It describes social interaction that happens while people are engaged in a shared activity rather than sitting face-to-face primarily to talk.


Why does walking make conversation easier?

Walking gives people a shared task, reduces constant eye contact, allows natural pauses and creates things to talk about. Not everyone finds it easier, but many do.


Do men disclose less than women?

Research reviewed in 2025 suggests men, on average, engage less often in vulnerable disclosure of distress, difficult emotions and requests for help, although there is substantial variation between individual men.


Is humour a way of avoiding feelings?

Sometimes. It can also simply be humour and an important way people bond. Context matters.


Will I have to talk about personal things at MoMENtum?

No. MoMENtum is a social connection group, not group therapy. Personal conversations may happen naturally, but they are not required.


Is MoMENtum suitable if I’m shy?

Potentially. Activity-based events can reduce pressure because there is something to do besides maintaining conversation.


What if I need more support than a social group can provide?

Use appropriate counselling, medical or specialist mental-health services. A social group can complement support but is not a substitute for treatment when treatment is needed.


How do I turn an acquaintance into a friend?

Repeated contact helps. Talk again, remember something from the previous conversation and eventually suggest doing something outside the original activity.


The MoMENtum question

Ask yourself:

“Do I actually need to ‘open up’ more — or do I need more people around me whom I’d eventually feel comfortable opening up to?”

I think those are often confused.

We keep telling men to talk.

But sometimes we haven't helped them build anyone worth talking to.

A stranger isn't automatically a support network.

Trust develops.

Friendships develop.

Belonging develops.

And often the route there is remarkably ordinary.

Walk together.

Do something.

Laugh.

See each other again.

Become familiar.

Then, one day, somebody says:

“Actually mate, it's been a rough week.”

Nobody scheduled vulnerability.

Nobody forced disclosure.

The relationship simply became strong enough to hold a slightly more honest conversation.

That's the kind of connection I want MoMENtum to make possible.

Not because men need fixing.

Not because every man secretly wants group therapy.

Because most of us do better when there are a few people around who know who we are.

And sometimes the easiest way to create that isn't by sitting down and talking.

It's by standing up and doing something together.

You don't have to open up to belong. Sometimes belonging is what makes opening up possible.

Comments


Momentum logo

Building stronger connections, one event, one conversation and one friendship at a time.

Don't worry! We won't spam you!

  • Facebook
  • Instagram

Copyright © 2025 by Momentum | All Rights Reserved.

bottom of page