The Mask of Perfection, the Fear of Vulnerability, and the Cost of Silence
- Alan Stokes
- Oct 3
- 4 min read
Men and the mask we learn to wear
From an early age, many men are told don’t show weakness, don’t mess up, don’t get it wrong. So we build masks. We hold it together. We avoid the conversations that make us sweat.
I know this because I’ve lived it. As a boy, I learned to protect myself from rejection by trying to be perfect. As a man in relationships, I believed silence kept me safe.
But silence didn’t protect me. It created distance. It damaged trust. It left me carrying weight I didn’t know how to put down.
And I’m not alone. Research shows that men are far less likely than women to seek help for mental health difficulties — stigma, pride, and fear of judgment keep many of us stuck behind a mask.
The pressure to be perfect
Perfectionism isn’t striving for excellence. It’s fear:
Fear of failure.
Fear of not being enough.
Fear of being judged.
A study published in Psychological Bulletin (2018) found that perfectionism has risen dramatically over the last three decades, particularly in younger generations of men. The pressure to look like we’ve “got it all together”—physically, emotionally, professionally—fuels shame and anxiety.
I once believed being perfect would keep me safe. Instead, it made me smaller. I stopped sharing my voice. I kept people at a distance.
Perfectionism isn’t protection. It’s a cage. It kills creativity, blocks connection, and feeds depression and burnout.
Why vulnerability feels weak but isn’t
Most men dodge vulnerability. We bury feelings. We change the subject. Why? Because it feels like weakness—like handing someone a weapon they could use against us.
But that’s a lie. Vulnerability isn’t weakness; it’s courage in action.
It’s telling the truth even when your voice shakes.It’s admitting, “I don’t have the answer.”It’s letting someone in when every instinct tells you to shut them out.
Researcher Dr Brené Brown defines vulnerability as “uncertainty, risk, and emotional exposure.” It’s uncomfortable—but it’s also the foundation of trust, love, and connection.
I avoided vulnerability for years. And it cost me. My silence cracked relationships wide open. What I thought was strength was actually fear in disguise.
The hidden cost of avoidance
Silence always sends a bill. Here’s what it costs:
Disconnection – If you never show who you are, nobody really knows you.
Resentment – Buried feelings don’t disappear; they ferment.
Stress and burnout – Pretending burns energy like running with weights.
Loneliness – The UK Men’s Health Forum highlights that suicide is one of the leading causes of death in men under 50. Avoidance isolates—and isolation kills.
Avoidance doesn’t protect you. It delays the truth until it erupts—often harder and harsher than if you’d faced it sooner.
What real strength looks like
Strength isn’t silence. Strength isn’t perfection. Strength is showing up when it’s uncomfortable.
Saying “I need help” when your instinct is to soldier on.
Telling your partner what you actually feel instead of shutting down.
Being honest with your mates instead of hiding behind banter.
Sitting in a room with other men and admitting, “Yeah, me too.”
That’s why we built MoMENtum Men’s Group. Because the world tells men to carry it all alone. But alone is killing us.
How to start dropping the mask: some practical steps
You don’t need to rip the mask off all at once. Start small, steady, and honest:
Name your feelings. Even awkwardly—“I feel tired,” “I feel anxious.” Language makes them real.
Choose one conversation this week to be honest in. Don’t dodge. Say the thing.
Redefine strength. When you want to hide, ask: What would courage look like right now?
Start small. Vulnerability is built on a series of honest moments, not one big confession.
Find your tribe. You can’t do this alone. Accountability and brotherhood make the difference.
The challenge
Men, here’s the truth: perfection isn’t protecting you. Avoidance isn’t saving you. Silence isn’t strength.
It’s time to drop the mask. To stop living behind armour. To start speaking the truth.
MoMENtum Men’s Group isn’t a therapy session or a pub chat. It’s a space for men to be real, to be held accountable, and to grow stronger together.
Because courage starts where comfort ends.
So I’ll ask you directly:👉 Where are you hiding behind perfection?👉 Where are you avoiding the truth?👉 And what’s it costing you?
Final word
For too long, I believed perfection made me strong and silence kept me safe. All it really did was make me smaller, lonelier, and more disconnected.
What changed everything was realising that vulnerability—the very thing I feared—was actually the key to connection and strength.
If you’re tired of carrying the mask, maybe it’s time to try something new.
Step into the arena. Join men who get it. Build momentum.
MoMENtum Men’s Group: For men ready to stop hiding and start living.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Is vulnerability really a weakness for men?No. Vulnerability is not weakness—it’s courage in practice. Research shows that men who express emotions and seek support build stronger relationships, reduce stress, and experience better well-being outcomes.
2. How do I start dropping the mask of perfection? Start small. Use “I feel…” statements, be honest in one conversation each week, and find supportive peers or groups who encourage authenticity. Progress comes from consistent, small acts of honesty.
3. Why is silence harmful to men’s mental health? Silence creates disconnection, stress, and isolation. The Men’s Health Forum notes that suicide is one of the leading causes of death in men under 50 in the UK. Breaking the silence through conversation and community is a proven step towards resilience and better mental health.
Author Bio
About the author, Alan R. Stokes is the founder of MoMENtum Men’s Group and Director of Horizon Counselling Services. A qualified counsellor and hypnotherapist with over 10,000 client hours, he is a registered member of BACP and supports men to build resilience, connection, and wellbeing across the UK.
Comments